The MG Windsor EV, the automaker’s third all-electric vehicle, debuted in India lately and retails for an alluring Rs 9.99 lakh (introductory ex-showroom countrywide). The catch is that you have to pay MG an extra Rs 3.5 for each kilometre you drive in order to rent a battery from them. However, its starting pricing is the same as the Tata Punch EV’s. Which option should you choose if both are available for around Rs 10 lakh?
Tata Punch EV vs MG Windsor EV : Prices
| Model | Price Range (ex-showroom) |
| MG Windsor EV | Rs 9.99 lakh |
| Tata Punch EV | Rs 9.99 lakh to Rs 14.29 lakh |
As of right now, MG has just revealed the Windsor EV’s starting price; the full range of costs for its various variants is unclear. But as was previously indicated, the battery rental for the Windsor EV is an extra expense of Rs 3.5 per kilometer, whereas this is not the case with the Punch EV. The costs of the Punch EV, ex-showroom, range from Rs 9.99 lakh to Rs 14.29 lakh.
Tata Punch EV vs MG Windsor EV: Dimension
| Parameter | MG Windsor EV | Tata Punch EV | Difference |
| Length | 4295 mm | 3857 mm | +438 mm |
| Width | 1850 mm (excluding ORVMs) | 1742 mm | +108 mm |
| Height | 1677 mm | 1633 mm | +44 mm |
| Wheelbase | 2700 mm | 2445 mm | +255 mm |
| Boot space | up to 604 litres | 366 litres | up to +238 litres |
The Windsor EV is a more substantial option than the Punch EV, as the table above illustrates. Its length of 4,295 mm allows for a wheelbase that is 255 mm longer, which is expected to improve internal space. It should be noted that the Windsor EV’s top-spec Essence model has 579 liters of boot space, while the Excite and Exclusive versions have 604 liters—up to 238 liters more than the Punch EV.
Tata Punch EV vs MG Windsor EV: Features
| Features | MG Windsor EV | Tata Punch EV |
| Exterior | Auto-LED projector headlightsConnected LED DRLsLED cornering lampsLED rear fog lamps18-inch dual-tone alloy wheelsFlush door handles | Auto-LED projector headlightsConnected LED DRLs with welcome and goodbye animationLED fog lamps with cornering function16-inch dual-tone alloy wheels |
| Interior | Black leatherette seat upholstery with contrasting gold and bronze highlights60:40 split-folding rear seats256-colour ambient lightingType-C USB charging ports for front and rear seat passengers | White leatherette seat upholstery with all-black dashboardFootwell lightningType-C USB charging ports for front row passengers only |
| Infotainment | 15.6-inch infotainment system with wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto9-speaker Infinity sound systemConnected car tech | 10.25-inch infotainment system with wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto6-speaker sound systemConnected car tech |
| Comfort Convenience | 8.8-inch digital driver’s displayVentilated front seatsPM2.5 air filterCruise control6-way power adjustable driver’s seatAutomatic climate control with rear ventsWireless phone chargerElectrically adjustable and foldable ORVMs with power-folding functionPanoramic glass roof | 10.25-inch digital driver’s displayVentilated front seatsAir purifierCruise controlManual height adjustable driver’s seatAutomatic climate controlWireless phone chargerPaddle shifters for regen brakingElectrically adjustable ORVMs with power-folding functionSingle-pane sunroof |
| Safety | 6 airbagsABS with EBDElectronic stability control360-degree cameraRear parking sensorsTyre pressure monitoring system (TPMS)ISOFIX child seat mountsHill-start assistHill-descent controlAll-wheel disc brakesElectronic parking brakeRain-sensing wipersRear defogger | 6 airbagsABS with EBDElectronic stability control360-degree cameraRear parking sensorsTyre pressure monitoring system (TPMS)ISOFIX child seat mountsHill-descent controlHill-hold controlAll-wheel disc brakesElectronic parking brakeRain-sensing wipersRear wiperRear defogger |
Tata Punch EV vs MG Windsor EV: Powertrain Options
| Powertrain Options | MG Windsor EV | Tata Punch EV | |
| Battery pack | 38 kWh | 25 kWh | 35 kWh |
| No of electric motor | 1 | 1 | 1 |
| Power/ Torque | 136 PS/200 Nm | 82 PS/114 Nm | 122/190 Nm |
| MIDC-claimed range | 331 km | 265 km | 365 km |
Tata has two different battery pack options for the Punch EV: a 25 kWh and a 35 kWh pack. Each has a single electric motor, and depending on the battery pack selected, the output varies. The larger unit has a claimed range of 365 km, while the smaller pack gives a claimed range of 265 km from MIDC.
On the other hand, the Windsor EV boasts a stated range of 331 km and is equipped with a single 38 kWh battery pack in conjunction with a more potent 136 PS and 200 Nm electric motor.
. The catch is that you have to pay MG an extra Rs 3.5){kind=link}